Thursday, April 19, 2007

VA Tech - DO NOT POST COMMENTS

As I mentioned in class, mixed in among the horror of Monday's events, there were some moments of great heroism. I was struck by the courage of Engineering Professor Liviu Librescu. Click on his name to see a 2-minute video about this professor.

I know in class I said that folks could write comments, if you choose, about the events of Monday. As I reflect more about those events, I think this is simply too public of a forum for us to share our personal thoughts about these events. I still encourage you to write about what happened so that you can begin to think through your feelings, but please keep your writing to yourself.

DO NOT post your comments here on the web (in fact, I have turned off the comments feature for this post).

We will talk in class about what happened, and if there is time, we will discuss the homework reading about life in the 1920s and women's suffrage.

See you tomorrow.

Saturday, April 14, 2007

Sorry Seems to be the Hardest Word -- Part II

Welcome back from break!

In the days since we left each other's company, several apologies have issued. Radio host Don Imus apologized to the Rutgers women's basketball team. The team accepted his apology. As a consequence for his comments, Don Imus has been fired from CBS Radio.

comment on YouTube about the apology:

LOL ...centuries??? blacks just got the right to vote in this country just 40 years ago!!! although yes we have been part of this damn ungrateful country since its founding ....PLEASE stop acting like it was ancient history ... that why the education system sucks


Mike Nifong apologized to the three Duke lacrosse players (but not in person). They have not accepted his apology. He's under investigation on charges that he suppressed exculpatory DNA evidence; that investigation may result in Mr. Nifong losing his license to practice law.

Here's a report from USA Today:

Durham County District Attorney Mike Nifong issued a statement supporting the dismissal of remaining charges against the three student-athletes a day after Attorney General Roy Cooper pronounced them innocent.

"To the extent that I made judgments that ultimately proved to be incorrect, I apologize to the three students who were wrongly accused," Nifong said.

One of the students, Colin Finnerty, told CBS' 60 Minutes: "It may be an apology, but it doesn't make me feel any better. … It was his actions more than anybody's that caused the harm."

In an interview with 60 Minutes to air Sunday night, Cooper went beyond his comments on Wednesday when he labeled Nifong a "rogue" prosecutor who had pursued the Duke case with a "tragic rush to accuse."

Finally, here's a letter of apology from Bill Clinton to the victims of Japanese internment camps during World War II. The US Government gave each living victim a check for $20,000. I'm not sure what happened if the victim's family was identified but the person had died already.

Oh, and moving from the federal to the state level, North Carolina's Senate did choose to apologize for slavery, and the house followed. What will the consequence be, if any? Will this apology matter? Should it have mentioned 1898 in the "whereas" section?

PART III -- Someone at the N&O also noticed the excessive amount of apologies this past week.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word

(with apologies to Sir Elton John)

First, read this article from the Council on Foreign Relations.

Then, read this article about Missouri's debate about whether that state should be the first U.S. state to apologize for slavery (there's a Dred Scott connection here).

Finally, please answer all three of the following questions in your post:

1. Should Japan apologize for the comfort women? Why or why not?

2. Should the United States apologize for slavery? Why or why not?

3. What are the plusses and/or minuses of a nation or a state admitting that it did something wrong?

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

Article about terrorism in Iraq

First, read this article.

Hmmm.. for some reason, the article keeps changing from the one Terran sent originally -- see if this link works (both articles are short, so please read both).

Whatever articles you end up reading, know that terrorists (nice discussion of who make up "terrorists" Michael -- there are many groups here) in Iraq are attacking Shiite pilgrims and blowing bombs in and around mosques.

In your posting, please consider these questions:

Why do the terrorists attack mosques if religion is one of the reasons people become suicide bombers?

If a quiet day in Iraq is one bomb going off and one person dying, are the people in Iraq doing enough, or do there need to be more troops to stop this violence?

Are troops even the answer to stopping the violence?

Tuesday, February 27, 2007

Darfur and the ICC

This is from Jonathan:

First of all read these three articles from the BBC:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/6399311.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/6401607.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/6402363.stm

If you are unfamiliar
with the Darfur Genocide there's this Wikipedia article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darfur_genocide).

Do you think that the ICC (International Criminal Court) is justified in naming two highly-placed Sudanese officials as war crimes suspects? Are the ICC's actions sufficient? too much? too little?

On a larger scale, why do you think the world has been ignoring Darfur for almost four years before even announcing allegations of war crimes? Should the US be more active? less active? in these allegations.

Finally, this link
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/6190148.stm is something a little extra to chew on-- the Sudanese president claims, "that the crisis in Darfur is in fact all made up."

Wednesday, February 07, 2007

Education

This is from Philip:

So my real question here is one that has no right
answer. I want to know which reform do you guys
things is better? Bush's proposal or the Democratic
proposal? Do you think that there's anything that can
be done that could stop or slow down the ridiculous
hike of costs for college? I think that this is
something that's relevant to everyone here, as I think
we all plan to attend college and the costs are only
increasing.

And here is the article he wants us to read.

Comment away!

UPDATE: Here's a new article about graduation rates in North Carolina.
The headline: Only 68% graduate on time in N.C.

Monday, February 05, 2007

Mexican Immigration in North Carolina

Please read this article from today's News and Observer and post a comment.

Screening flags illegal workers at N.C. sites

For more than a decade, it has been an open secret that many of the 5,000 workers at Smithfield Packing Co.'s gigantic Bladen County slaughterhouse were illegal immigrants.

Most everyone -- the company, the community and the government -- was willing to look the other way as thousands of Hispanic immigrants moved in, started families and even began to fight for better working conditions at the plant in the town of Tar Heel.

Now all that is changing.

The federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency has recently taken a keen interest in Smithfield, a Virginia company that is one of the world's largest pork producers, and many other large companies that rely on immigrant labor. Federal agents are combing through records at large plants nationwide, looking for fraudulent Social Security numbers. They are deporting people who believed that, after surviving the treacherous journey over the U.S. border, they were safe.

Twenty-one workers were arrested at the Smithfield plant last week and will probably be deported. Company officials say they will soon have to fire nearly 500 more workers if they can't explain why their Social Security numbers are invalid. Hispanics make up about half the 5,000 employees at the Tar Heel plant, the largest pork- processing facility in the world.

Company spokesman Dennis Pittman said Smithfield is cooperating with federal immigration officials because it fears sanctions if it doesn't.

Swift & Co., another large meat processor, saw more than 1,200 of its workers in six states arrested in a December immigration raid. And in the fall, a Georgia poultry plant, Crider Inc., lost more than 600 of its 900 employees in a raid.

"We need these people," Pittman said. "They're trained. They're good, hard-working employees. Some of them have been here six, seven, eight years. But if Homeland Security says they're not eligible to work here, we can't have them work here."

Going door-to-door

Federal immigration officials aren't just targeting large companies. In recent months, they have been going door to door to round up illegal immigrants, some of whom have been convicted of crimes.

Three such operations have been held in the Charlotte area since last spring, resulting in more than 200 arrests, said Richard Rocha, a spokesman for Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The last of the three was in January.

Most of those picked up were convicted drunk drivers, Rocha said. But a few happened to live or work where agents visited.

Rocha predicted more arrests in the coming months.

He said the agency will recruit more companies to sign up for a program that allows ICE to inspect employee records. He would not say how many companies have enrolled so far.

ICE is also training sheriff's departments, including three in North Carolina, to make immigration arrests, a practice that was banned until a recent federal law change enabled local police to help with immigration enforcement.

"We're doing what we need to do to restore integrity to the immigration system," Rocha said.

Get-tough attitude

Some say public outrage has forced the government to act. In the past year, grass-roots anti-immigration groups have gained steam.

The Minuteman Civil Defense Corps, known for conducting citizen border patrol operations, is expanding into non-border states, including North Carolina, training volunteers to confront business owners that they suspect of hiring illegal immigrants.

A North Carolina-based group, Americans for Legal Immigration, started a popular Web site where people can report employers they suspect of hiring illegal workers.

Rumors about Hispanic immigrants spreading disease, brutalizing U.S. citizens and even plotting to reconquer the southwest for Mexico have spread on the Internet.

"They're beginning to do their job," Ron Woodard of Cary, founder of a nonprofit group that opposes illegal immigration, said of ICE officials. "Illegals are going to get the message that, if you come here the wrong way, your days are numbered."

This get-tough attitude has support among many in Washington.

Laura Caudell, a spokesman for U.S. Sen. Richard Burr, a Republican from Winston-Salem, said Burr is pleased about the crackdown. But she also said he will push for immigration reform.

"He believes those who break the law must be held accountable," Caudell said. "He wants the Senate to pass comprehensive immigration reform legislation which will include an effective temporary worker program."

Some argue that, in a country with an estimated 12 million illegal immigrants, arresting a few thousand people is political show.

"If there are some sensational things, like big raids or a wall built, or even talk of building a wall, that gives politicians some cover to say, 'Look, I'm getting tough. Now I'm going to vote for immigration reform,' " said Altha Cravey, a UNC-Chapel Hill geography professor who is writing a book on Mexican migration.

Cravey pointed out that, even though Congress passed legislation last year to build a wall along the Mexican border, the project has not been funded.

Living in fear

Advocates say that Hispanics now live in fear of being yanked from their homes or workplaces. They say ICE is victimizing families who have lived in North Carolina for years without incident.

"What we need is a complete reform of our immigration system," said Marisol Jimenez McGee, advocacy director with El Pueblo, a nonprofit agency that helps Hispanic immigrants. "So why are they going after families and creating terror in our communities?"

Eduardo Pena, a worker advocate and union organizer at the Smithfield plant, said he met last weekend with the families of those who were arrested. He said they are struggling to find out where their family members are and what charges they face.

In many cases, he said, they have lost the family's sole breadwinner. Some have U.S.-born children and few connections left in Mexico.

At the plant, the Hispanic workers who remain live in fear, Pena said. He said rumors of immigration raids spread through the plant regularly, forcing Hispanic workers to flee.

"It reminds me of an island where a hurricane is coming," Pena said. "People are getting ready for disaster."

* * *


Friday, January 26, 2007

Responding to your comments

What great comments. Congratulations on your collective engagement with current events!

It seemed like three issues dominated the discussion -- Mexico, Iraq and Global Warming. People also brought up the graying of America, healthcare, and whether it makes sense for the U.S. to have troops in so many places around the world.

Cami asked a great question (historia!) about the definition of an earmark.

In these discusisons, I hope to serve as the "fact and logic police," correcting any factual errors or errors in logic that I notice in the discussion. I won't often enter the discussion. The goal is for you folks to have a space to discuss further the issues you raised online. If this is a good discussion (as I am sure it will be), please do continue the discussion online.

Starting with Mexico, there are public schools in Mexico. In fact, here's an article from Business Week, titled Mexico's Classrooms go Multimedia. Of course that article does not apply to all classrooms in Mexico, but if you are picturing Mexicans in backwards classrooms, perhaps you should think again :)

Here are some facts about Mexico's middle class that I have not yet been able to verify, but they might be an interesting starting point for further research. Because there seems to be so much interest about Mexico, perhaps we should look at the history of US-Mexican relations, starting with the Mexican War in the 1840s.

In Iraq, the financial cost of the war thus far is between one and two trillion dollars. Here's another source with a similar estimate. The figure Xavier cited, of about $200 million a day, seems about right -- though there are some estimates of closer to $300 million a day. We should definitely discuss further whether the proposed "surge" of 20,000 troops makes sense. If it does not make sense, what course of action would you propose?

As for global warming, let's take a look at the Kyoto Protocol. Here's a quick definition from Wikipedia:

The Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change is an amendment to the international treaty on climate change, assigning mandatory targets for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions to signatory nations.

Here's a summary of the U.S. position, from the same Wikipedia article.

If someone wants to do a research paper on any of these topics -- Mexican-U.S. immigration, The War in Iraq, or Global Warming, please let me know. All of those would be great topics.

Wednesday, January 24, 2007

The State of the Union in 2007

Wednesday evening, President Bush delivered the State of the Union address to Congress, the Supreme Court, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the President's cabinet.

Compare the President's address to the Democratic response, and post, by Thursday night at 9 p.m., your thoughts about the state of the United States as we begin 2007. Post your thoughts as a comment on the class site. If you are not the first to post, read what your classmates wrote, and try to respond, respectfully, to what they have to say. Ideally, you should ask some questions that we as a class can work to answer.

For example, President Bush did not mention New Orleans in his speech, and Senator Webb criticized him for not mentioning it. What is the current state of affairs in New Orleans? What has the federal government done to help? Whose responsibility is it to help New Orleans rebuild? Should New Orleans rebuild, given its precarious position?

Monday, February 13, 2006

Darfur Genocide 2006

Since the genocide began in early 2003, approximately 3 million members of the Fur, Masalit and Zaghawa tribes in Darfur, Sudan, have been displaced and 200-400,000 people have been killed.

Here's an audio slideshow titled On The Ground in Darfur.

Here's a short but powerful video about the Darfur genocide that one of my students from last year found. This video is a great place to start if you want to introduce someone (or yourself) to the issue.

The NewsHour on PBS just covered Darfur on April 25.

And here's an excellent hour-long program from the U.S. Holocaust Museum about Darfur, from April 17.

An extensive collection of resources about Darfur is available further down on this website.

If you care about the ongoing genocide in the Sudan, there's a Rally to Stop Genocide on Sunday, April 30, on the National Mall in Washington, DC. Many speakers will be there, and it will be a great way to get ideas about how to put increasing pressure on Congress and President Bush to do more to help end this genocide.

Here's a fact sheet about the rally, which runs from 2-4:30 p.m. A group of us will meet near the National Gallery at 12:30 p.m. for lunch. If you are interested in joining us, please email me and I'll get you more details.

click on the map below to make it easier to read
The rally will take place on the Mall between 3rd and 4th Streets, NW, right in front of the U.S. Capitol.
(just south of the East building of the National Gallery of Art on the map above)

Here's a picture of what the rally site looked like the day before the rally:


And here's what it looked like on the day of the rally, from the viewpoint of ABC's Will Bressman.

Below is an extensive collection of materials about Darfur:

The New York Times' Nicholas Kristof (who just won the 2006 Pulitzer Prize for his commentary) recently made his sixth trip to the Darfur area. This time, his multimedia presentation comes from the Chad-Darfur border.

For more information, see this Flash Video and this page with a link to more video.

PBS's NewsHour, on Feb 16, interviewed Senators Barack Obama (D-Ill) and Sam Brownback (R-KS) about the situation in Darfur.

Although there is no video we know of that shows the villages being attacked by planes, helicopters, and janjaweed (armed men on horses or camels), some children in refugee camps in Chad made some drawings of what happened to them.

Here's a video that explains more about these images drawn by children.

Then, look at this video of destroyed villages.

This is a documentary on the crisis in Darfur made by IRIN, the U.N.'s Integrated Regional Information Network.

And these pictures from a series titled In Darfur, My Camera Was Not Nearly Enough.

The targeted groups of the genocide are the Fur, the Masalit and the Zaghawa.

Eric Reeves has an amazing blog on Darfur. He's an English professor at Smith College, and he has
spent the past seven years working full-time as a Sudan researcher and analyst, publishing extensively both in the US and internationally.

The BBC has a good in-depth look at Sudan.

For some geographic perspective, see this article with accompanying maps of the area.

And look at this State Department report from 2004 (it contains many useful charts and maps).

You can also listen to Nicholas Kristof talk about the situation in Darfur with Romeo Dallaire, the U.N. commander who was powerless to stop the genocide in Rwanda in 1994.

Senator Barack Obama delivers a 7-minute podcast on 2/15/06 --
Darfur: Current Policy Not Enough.

This is an okay documentary in 10 minutes, but it will not GRAB high school students. Can we make one that will???

Again, not a bad high school effort in 2 minutes. But we can do better!

Here's a half hour report on Sudan.

And here are ten things you can do if you want to get involved in stopping the genocide in Darfur.

* * *

You can also learn about Ethiopia here.

Friday, February 03, 2006

Cartoons about Muhammad in Europe

Some cartoons were published in a Danish newspaper in late September of 2005 depicting the prophet Muhammad in unflattering and offensive ways.

This article from the BBC explains the meaning of the 12 cartoons.

The cartoons led to major protests across the Muslim world.

(here is an intriguing map of where Muslims are in the world)

The New York Times has a nice timeline tracing the cartoon protests.

The cartoons currently in the news raise the issue:

How free should freedom of speech be?

There are some limits to free speech in the United States -- but speech here is far freer than in almost any other nation.

The main categories of speech not protected in the U.S. are

Defamation | Causing panic | Fighting words | Incitement to crime | Sedition | Obscenity

For a discussion of each, click here.


For some additional context, see this speech from a first amendment website.



Here is another account of the cartoon scandal, from Wikipedia.